Demonstration in city streets advocating for Palestinian freedom.

Good Law Project Challenges Government Over Antisemitism Definition In Schools

Good Law Project has taken the first step towards a legal challenge over the government’s decision to encourage schools to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s (IHRA) definition of antisemitism.

The organisation announced on 2 November that it had issued a pre-action protocol letter to the government, raising concerns about the implications for teachers’ and pupils’ freedom of expression, particularly when discussing Israel and Palestine.

A pre-action protocol letter sets out a proposed legal challenge before court proceedings. The announcement does not establish that proceedings have been issued or that a court has ruled on the policy.

According to Good Law Project, the government’s decision followed its acceptance in full of recommendations from the Bell review, including a recommendation to encourage schools to adopt the IHRA definition.

The organisation argues that the definition and its accompanying examples risk restricting legitimate criticism of the Israeli state and expressions of solidarity with Palestinians. It points to objections from critics of the definition, including the Jewish group Na’amod.

The IHRA definition is accompanied by eleven illustrative examples. Good Law Project’s objections focus on examples relating to Israel, which it argues could lead schools to conflate political criticism with antisemitism.

The organisation has also questioned the evidence underpinning the Bell review. It argues that findings concerning increased “anti-Israel” sentiment should be distinguished from evidence of “anti-Jewish” attitudes.

In its announcement, Good Law Project highlighted the review’s acknowledgement that “a low sample size of 92 students who identify as Jewish should be treated with caution”. The organisation argues that the sample size and limited pupil age range raise questions about the conclusions drawn.

A further concern is how the recommendations would operate alongside schools’ existing measures to address racism and bullying. Good Law Project cited criticism from the National Education Union, which warned that the approach risked “creating a hierarchy of racism”.

Good Law Project’s executive director, Jo Maugham, said:

“It is not merely important to protect the space to advance vigorous criticisms of Israel’s appalling actions – we think it is necessary in a moral society.”

The proposed challenge centres on how schools can address antisemitism while protecting lawful political discussion and freedom of expression. The supplied announcement did not include a government response to the pre-action letter.

 

—

Image: Pixabay.com

Previous post Listening to learners to shape the future of skills in Wales
Next post Chester student to celebrate 17th birthday at Rugby League World Cup alongside dad