A-level results should be a wake-up call on girls and STEM
By Emma Williams, MyEdSpace Biology teacher
This year’s A-level results should be a wake-up call – not because boys have suddenly become better at education, but because we are still failing to get enough girls into some of the subjects that will shape the future.
Boys have taken a record lead over girls in achieving A* and A grades this year, with 28.9% of boys achieving the top grades compared with 28% of girls. But look underneath that headline and there is a much more interesting story. Boys continue to be heavily overrepresented in STEM subjects: 81% of A-level computing entries are male, alongside 76% in physics and 74% in further maths.
As a science teacher, I find that incredibly frustrating.
I have colleagues who have taught some outstanding female maths students over the years in both maths and further maths, but they are, unfortunately, small in number. They often find it can be a real challenge to convince a top female GCSE student that they can be successful at A-level.
That is the part of this debate we need to focus on. It isn’t about telling girls that they aren’t good at maths or science. Quite the opposite. It is about making sure talented girls see these subjects as being for them.
In science classrooms, I see the same potential. Girls can be hugely engaged, curious and ambitious in science, yet somewhere between those early years and choosing their A-level subjects, too many appear to decide that STEM isn’t for them.
The answer has to start much earlier than A-level.
By the time a student is making their sixth-form choices, we may already have spent years inadvertently telling them what subjects are “for” them. We need to give girls more opportunities to see what STEM actually looks like in the real world, and to meet people who can make those careers feel tangible and achievable.
That means inspirational visitors, meaningful exposure to STEM careers, work experience and, importantly, opportunities for girls to engage with STEM in environments where they feel confident enough to explore it.
I have seen mixed schools run girl-only science sessions and STEM-focused trips, and the feedback from both teachers and students was always very positive. I don’t have the data to say exactly what impact those initiatives had on outcomes, but they created an environment in which girls were more willing to engage with STEM – and that matters.
We also need to think seriously about STEM teaching in primary schools. We need more STEM specialist expertise and more opportunities for children to see science, technology, engineering and maths in action from an early age. That is particularly important when specialist provision is already under pressure.
There is an obvious role here for online education too. We can give pupils access to high-quality specialist teaching, engaging resources and experiences that might not otherwise be available in every school.
And we need visible role models. Hannah Fry is doing a fantastic job of building a recognisable presence on social media, and that visibility matters. A high-achieving girl sitting her GCSEs needs to be able to look at someone like that and think: I could do that too.
The lesson from this year’s results shouldn’t be that boys are better at A-levels. It should be that subject choice matters enormously – and that the subjects most closely associated with quantitative skills, STEM and many of the careers of the future remain heavily male dominated.
If we want more women in STEM careers in ten or twenty years’ time, we have to start by convincing more girls that science, maths and computing belong to them too. This year’s results give us another opportunity to do exactly that. We shouldn’t waste it.