Cozy office setup with a laptop, keyboard, pen, and coffee cup on a desk.

When everyone advertises the same way, the good job disappears

Recruitment advice usually treats the job advert as a piece of writing. Get the wording right, get the benefits in early, avoid the clichés. It assumes the advert is read on its own.

It is not. It is read in a list, next to competitors, and the list has a shape.

We re-read 541 UK teaching assistant adverts from their original pages, taking the structured fields for pay, hours and contract type rather than the job description. Teaching assistants are a useful test case because the role exists in two forms at once: a salaried school post, and a temporary agency placement paid by the day.

The advertised market is overwhelmingly the second kind.

Of the adverts stating an actual pay figure, 77.5% quote a day rate, typically £85 to £120. About one in ten quote an annual salary. Of the adverts stating a contract type, 39.4% are temporary and 25.0% are contract, against 35.6% permanent. So 64.4% of what is advertised is not a permanent job.

The concentration is the part worth pausing on

All 541 adverts came from 43 distinct advertisers. One supply agency accounted for 140 of them, more than a quarter of everything we read.

That is not a market of many employers competing. It is a small number of agencies posting a similar role across many locations, plus a minority of direct employers advertising among them.

We checked the pattern was not one advertiser dragging the average. Counting each employer once rather than each advert, 8 of the 12 advertisers with three or more listings mostly quote day rates. Removing the largest agency entirely still leaves 71.3%.

Why this is an HR problem and not an education one

Any employer advertising a permanent, salaried role into a channel like this has a presentation problem they did not create.

Their vacancy appears in the same list, in the same template, with the same fields, as a temporary placement. A candidate scanning results sees two numbers that are not comparable, £110 and £22,000, and no obvious cue as to which listing offers security. The contract type sits in a field most candidates never read.

The result is that the better offer is the harder one to recognise. The employer paying for permanence, holiday and progression is competing against a headline number that looks larger per unit of time and is not.

This happens wherever a channel tilts heavily to one contract type. Warehouse and driving work behaves the same way in periods of heavy agency use, and so does hospitality. Teaching assistants simply show it unusually clearly, because the day rate and the salary sit side by side in the same feed.

There is also a disclosure gap that makes the comparison harder. Only 16.3% of these adverts state that the role is term-time only, and 20.3% mention term-time at all. For a role that is overwhelmingly term-time, that is the single fact needed to convert a day rate into an annual figure, and four adverts in five leave it out. It is the same problem we found across 33 occupations when we looked at how UK adverts state pay, where a third of advertised “ranges” turned out to be the same number stated twice.

Three things to change if you advertise into a channel like this

**Put the contract type in the title, not the field.** If the post is permanent, say so where a scanning candidate reads, not in a structured field below the fold. In this market only about a third of listings can make that claim, which makes it the cheapest differentiator available.

**Quote pay on the basis the candidate is comparing.** If the rest of the list is quoting day rates, an annual salary alone invites a bad comparison. Give the annual figure and the working pattern that produces it.

**State the working pattern in the first paragraph.** Term-time, shift pattern, guaranteed hours, whichever applies. Candidates who discover it after shortlisting are the ones who withdraw after shortlisting, and that cost lands on you.

What this does not say

One board, one snapshot, weighted towards agencies. Employers advertising directly on their own sites are not in this sample. Nothing here measures how teaching assistants are actually employed across England, only what a candidate sees when they look. The concentration figure in particular is a property of the channel we sampled, not a national statistic.

 

About the Author

Anthony Clasper is the founder of Sausage Dog, a UK CV tool built on original analysis of 16,000+ UK job adverts.

The full analysis of all 541 teaching assistant adverts, including the pay-period breakdown and the employer concentration checks: https://sausagedog.io/blog/teaching-assistant-day-rate-adverts

How UK adverts state pay across 33 occupations: https://sausagedog.io/blog/uk-job-advert-salary-ranges

two women writing on a white board with sticky notes Previous post Teaching assistant adverts ask about safeguarding eight times more often than GCSEs
Next post Table tennis partnership serves up skills and opportunities for next generation