When More Marketing Becomes Less Effective – A Lesson for Education

By Adam Herbert, CEO and Co-founder, Go Live Data

There is a widely held belief that successful marketing is simply a question of doing more of it. More emails, more automation and more touchpoints.

For many organisations, that thinking has become almost instinctive. Marketing technology has made it easier than ever to communicate with customers, prospects and partners, so why wouldn’t you take advantage of every opportunity?

Yet some of the strongest relationships are built through restraint, not frequency,

It’s a lesson that resonates particularly strongly across the education sector, where colleges, universities and independent training providers are investing heavily in employer engagement. Whether supporting apprenticeship programmes, developing commercial partnerships or working alongside local industry to address regional skills gaps, meaningful relationships with employers have never been more important.

Ironically, the technology designed to strengthen those relationships can sometimes begin to undermine them.

Across most institutions, employer communications originate from several different departments. Employer engagement teams, apprenticeship specialists, business development professionals, marketing departments and senior leaders all have perfectly legitimate reasons to contact businesses. Each campaign is planned with good intention, whereby each communication has a purpose and each team measures success against its own objectives.

The employer, however, sees none of that internal structure, as they only experience one organisation.

It could mean an invitation to an apprenticeship briefing, a request to join an advisory board next week, a networking event a few days later and a survey shortly afterwards, followed by funding updates, newsletters and invitations to awards or showcase events.

Viewed individually, every communication appears reasonable but viewed collectively, they can feel relentless for the recipient.

That distinction matters because employer engagement is relationship building in its purest sense.

Businesses choose to collaborate with education providers because they see value in doing so. They want access to talent, opportunities to shape future skills, meaningful partnerships and organisations that understand the pressures they face. Every communication either reinforces that confidence or slowly erodes it.

We’ve become accustomed to measuring marketing activity by volume. Open rates, click-throughs, campaign numbers and database growth all have their place, but they don’t necessarily tell us how recipients actually feel about the organisations communicating with them.

That’s where many organisations unknowingly decide to create friction.

The ability to automate communication has encouraged us to focus on what technology allows us to do, rather than what recipients actually need. Every interaction creates another trigger, another workflow or another opportunity to follow up. Before long, businesses aren’t hearing from one college or training provider. They’re hearing from five different departments, each believing they are the only conversation taking place, so the reality is very different.

Employer relationships are cumulative. Every interaction contributes to a wider perception of the institution. The recipient doesn’t separate communications into departments. They judge the organisation as a whole. Consistency, professionalism and respect for their time become every bit as important as the information being shared.

This is where I believe education can learn something from the wider B2B marketing world.

At Go Live Data, we’ve spent considerable time exploring what we call Frequency Rules. It isn’t a complicated principle. Before asking whether someone can receive another communication, organisations should ask whether they should. It’s that small shift that changes everything.

Instead of each department operating independently, communications should be coordinated. Priority should be given to relevance rather than volume, whereby employers receive information when it genuinely adds value, not simply because a workflow has reached its next stage.

Counterintuitively, communicating less, can produce stronger engagement. As well as this, it demonstrates confidence, respects attention and most importantly, it creates space for each communication to carry more weight. Artificial intelligence will only make this conversation more relevant.

AI is already helping organisations personalise content, identify buying signals, predict engagement and automate increasingly sophisticated communication journeys. Those capabilities will continue to improve, offering education providers valuable opportunities to strengthen employer relationships.

AI, however, can’t make strategic judgements about trust.

It won’t recognise when an organisation is close to overwhelming a valued employer with too many competing messages. It can’t decide that silence, on occasion, may be

the most effective communication strategy available. It’s those decisions that still rely on human judgement.

Advances in technology are changing the rules of engagement. Success will depend less on the volume of communications and more on the discipline behind every interaction.

Education has always been built on long-term relationships. Employers invest years in supporting apprenticeships, influencing curriculum development, providing industry expertise and helping shape future workforces. Those partnerships deserve communications that reflect the same level of care and consideration.

And perhaps that’s the real lesson. In an increasingly automated world, knowing when not to communicate may prove to be one of the most valuable marketing skills of all.

Previous post Green Flag continues to fly over Swansea University’s campuses
Next post Malvern College students win international science and innovation title