man in white crew neck t-shirt standing on road during daytime

Why voluntary national standards for non-school alternative provision matter

Written by Ed Robbins

The numbers speak for themselves. In 2023/24, 10,900 pupils were permanently excluded from state schools in England – a 16 per cent jump from the year before. At the same time, around 47,600 children were taught in state-funded alternative provision [AP] settings, also up 16 per cent on the previous year.

Behind these figures are thousands of young people who are finding mainstream education extremely challenging. For some, it’s a story of repeated exclusion and disengagement while, for others, it’s about unmet special educational needs or the impact of trauma and unstable home lives. Whatever the reason, the need for high-quality, supportive alternative provision has never been greater.

That’s why the Department for Education’s new voluntary national standards for non-school AP are so significant. They set out what good practice should look like, from safeguarding and staff quality to curriculum design and pupil welfare. Although they’re voluntary, the standards mark an important step towards greater consistency and accountability in a sector that’s long been patchy and misunderstood. Most importantly, they give children and families confidence that alternative provision can be safe and effective.

Meeting the needs of vulnerable learners

Alternative provision exists for pupils who often have the most complex needs, such as those with special educational needs and disabilities [SEND], social, emotional and mental health [SEMH] challenges or long histories of exclusion. Many arrive at AP settings carrying heavy emotional baggage, like frustration, fear or a deep sense that education just isn’t for them.

For these young people, school isn’t just about exams or grades, it’s a route to stability, confidence and a chance to rebuild. The new standards recognise this, highlighting that learning in these settings has to be personal, flexible and responsive.

Research from the Department for Education backs this up. Targeted interventions that focus on SEND and SEMH needs have been shown to increase engagement and reduce exclusion. Students in well-structured AP settings are more likely to re-engage with learning, attend regularly and achieve more, especially when teaching is adapted to their pace and ability rather than forced from above.

Curriculum design plays a big part in this. The standards promote alignment with mainstream education, but they also allow room for flexibility, which is a vital balance for pupils whose experiences have been disrupted or inconsistent. Progress might not always be linear, but improvements in wellbeing and social skills often pave the way for better academic outcomes further down the line.

The role of commissioners and providers

High-quality AP relies on strong partnerships between commissioners and providers. Commissioners must make sure placements are purposeful, time-limited and focused on helping students reintegrate where possible. Providers, meanwhile, need to deliver education that feels safe, engaging and genuinely supportive – not just academically, but emotionally as well.

Good communication is at the heart of this. Regular review meetings, open data-sharing and careful monitoring of outcomes help ensure placements are doing what they’re meant to do. The voluntary standards make this collaboration easier, giving both sides a shared language and a clear sense of what ‘good’ looks like.

Personalisation is also key. Many pupils in AP have faced repeated setbacks in mainstream environments, but smaller classes, specialist teaching and access to therapeutic support can make a world of difference. When students feel seen and supported, they begin to trust again, and that’s often where real learning starts.

Supporting wellbeing and mental health

Mental health needs are widespread among children in alternative provision. Research from the National Children’s Bureau suggests around 60 per cent of AP pupils have an identified mental health need, and nearly half have additional SEND requirements. These challenges can’t be treated as separate from education – they’re intertwined.

The voluntary standards put safeguarding and wellbeing front and centre. They encourage trauma-informed approaches, predictable routines and consistent emotional support. The aim is to create safe environments where pupils can rebuild confidence and resilience.

Evidence shows that when AP settings invest in mental health support and emotional care, they see gains in attendance, engagement and academic progress too. Stability and belonging often come before achievement, but they’re just as important.

Embedding accountability and professional growth

As well as supporting pupils, the new standards aim to help professionalise the sector. Clear benchmarks and tangible outcomes make it easier for providers to demonstrate quality and for commissioners to identify effective practice. Greater transparency can only strengthen public trust in alternative provision as a critical part of the education system.

Staff development is a central theme here. When expectations are clear, training and career progression become easier to build around them. Skilled staff [especially those experienced in SEMH, SEND and trauma-informed practice] are essential for ensuring AP isn’t just a stopgap, but a place where lives genuinely change direction.

Looking ahead

The publication of these standards is a big step, but it’s only the start. Real change will come through adoption, consistent implementation and ongoing reflection. Future revisions will need to keep pace with the world around us, including new thinking around digital learning, mental health and the needs of children growing up in increasingly complex circumstances.

For too long, alternative provision has been seen as a last resort, but these standards offer a different perspective. They help finally position AP as a vital, respected strand of inclusive education that provides tailored, high-quality support for children who need it most. With collaboration and accountability, AP can help young people rebuild confidence, rediscover their potential and find a path that works for them.

Final thoughts

Voluntary national standards give the alternative provision sector something it’s needed for a long time – a shared framework for quality, safety and consistency. They recognise the huge diversity within the sector while setting a clear expectation that every child, whatever their background or circumstances, deserves an education that’s safe, supportive and empowering.

Providers and commissioners who choose to embrace these standards won’t just be ticking boxes – they’ll be helping reshape how we think about education for vulnerable learners.

The tools are now in place to raise the bar. Now it’s our job to make sure every pupil in non-school settings has the best possible chance to succeed.

About the author

Ed Robbins is CEO of Fresh Start In Education

person using pencil Previous post Are SATs Failing Our Children? Parents Highlight Mental Health Impact
woman in black long sleeve shirt Next post New Research Shows Higher‑attaining maths pupils learn more in attainment‑based groups