How can schools guard against AI-assisted compensation claims?
Written by Sam King, Solicitor, Commercial Litigation, Forbes Solicitors
The complaints that will land on a school leader’s desk for the 2026/27 academic year look noticeably different to how they would have two or three years ago: longer, more formal, and confidently citing legal terminology. This is largely down to the rise in AI tools, and schools need to know how to respond in order to protect themselves.
Local councils have paid out £3.75 million over the past two years across more than 6,000 compensation claims for what have been called “ordinary childhood accidents”. This includes £20,000 awarded to a child who tripped while running towards a bouncy castle. Schools haven’t become less safe, and it isn’t necessarily that there are more legitimate grievances. What has changed is how easily parents and guardians can compile and submit a lengthy formal complaint.
How AI is changing school complaints
Generative AI gives parents the tools to turn what might otherwise have been a quick conversation or a brief email into an instant, polished-looking dossier. They tend to run considerably longer than a parent would have written unaided, and often request detailed investigations or unusual evidence, adding extra pressure to an already-stretched workload.
They also tend to include legally technical language, even where it’s inaccurate. The amplified, formal language can be intimidating for the staff handling complaints, who shouldn’t be expected to be legal experts on top of their many other duties.
This isn’t a reason to treat suspected AI- assisted complaints with suspicion. Many will be genuine, where AI has given a parent who would otherwise have struggled to put their concern into words a way to do so. Parents may have sought advice from a LLM and ended up more convinced that they have a strong claim, which may not be the case.
Dealing with the wave of claims
It’s tempting to use the volume or formality of a claim as an indication of how serious it is. It’s just as easy to dismiss AI-generated claims as opportunistic. Neither is a helpful stance; a short and informal concern raised by a parent deserves the same scrutiny as a long and confidently-worded one. Meanwhile, a polished complaint is no guarantee that the underlying claim is strong.
The safest approach is to separate the way a claim is presented from what it’s actually alleging, and get to the bottom of what a parent is ultimately looking to achieve. The substance should be assessed on its own strength each time.
Building protection into complaints processes
There are a number of ways that schools can protect against the rise in claims. The first is incident reporting; records made at the time of an incident that are specific to what happened, who was there, what was done in response, and when and how a parent or guardian was informed.
As claims grow in both number and length, staff will need support to manage the increase. Complaints policies should be updated and robust, setting out clear timescales for both parents and the school. Some schools impose overly restrictive deadlines on themselves, but it’s important that any promises made are realistic to deliver, so schools don’t set themselves up to fail. The policy should also clearly indicate when to bring in external legal advisers to manage more legally complex complaints.
With the new school year fast approaching, schools should be ready for any concern, however small, to arrive as a formal claim, and prepare to judge each one on the facts rather than the format.